Mine has to be Gimli, not only is he small and hardy but he beats Legolas in competion to see who can kill the most orcs at Helms Deep. Also im a sucker for Dwarfes.
Where there Nazgul in the Fellowship? Oh... no...Is there an Option for the nazgul? Your forcing me to vote for Freaking Boromir since he at least tried to kill the hobbits! (May i suggest a Kill the Hobbits selection?)