Warhammer 40k Forum and Wargaming Forums banner
1 - 5 of 5 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
Hey guys,

So instead of doing homework I decided to work on this little "gem". So far I only have the "Small" ships in the file, since they I feel are a little easier to manage.

Its an excel file that I created to see how "Balanced" the game is, Since I was trying to figure out why certain ships (here it is TIE Advances, and before Rebel Aces A-Wings too) do not get played by the masses.

And since this is a 40k friendly area where we all know about "Math Hammer", however justifiable it is to use on an unbalanced game such as 40k, I figured that I would give it a try on X-wing.

In short this is the math That I used for THESE Numbers...

All Pilot Skill, Attack, and Evade values are equal in points as to their value.

Hull values are equal to 3 points per hull (Modification card to increase Hull is 3 points)

Shield Values are equal to 4 points per shield (Modification card to increase Shield is 4 points)

Ships "Ability" is debatable, since how I found this number is to take the highest "normal" pilot and add 1 point per Pilot Skill increase to come to the same PS as the named character. So often times Pilots do NOT have a point value for these upgrades, or at most only 1 point. Some ships get more, for instance Major Rhymer's (PS 7 TIE Bomber) ability is basically worth 5 points, while Tetran Cowall's ability is worth 0.

In short for the Empire there are 3 ships that give you a "bonus" for taking them, TIE Fighters, and TIE Bombers are sorta expected to be in those slots, but the fact that TIE Advances actually "GIVE AWAY" free points is rather shocking for me to find, since there are practically NEVER fielded, and most people who I know have them, only play them rarely since Interceptors out perform them by far on the table, despite the fact that the Interceptors actually cost the player points to use. Royal Guard are the best ships to use with this knowledge, although I feel that most people are still willing to make use of the other pilots.

----

On the flip side the Rebels almost universally make gains with their ships, with ONLY the E-Wing effectively costing the player points. A-Wings, without Chardaan refit, actually put you ahead on points yet the ships often feel too expensive/not useful enough whenever given a missile which is often weird when the ships are designed to basically give the player a free 3 point missile (proton rockets anyone?)

----

In general I think Fantasy Flights actual "model" is not too far off from my own, perhaps granting the 1st PS, Attack, Evade, and Hull for free and only charging full price (or whatever value that they wish) for the rest.

Please Discuss.
 

·
Warlord of Vermin
Joined
·
882 Posts
nice work, personally i dont really understand the whole points thing, i never used the original math hammer, but nice work


i dont really play much x-wing because the only opponent i have is my brother and he gets bored by it and gets irritated when his ships collide with mine
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,323 Posts
I've been pondering this, and I think you're very close to being spot on with your allocation of points. Something I just noticed with Interceptor pilots, Boost, and 1 point per stat-line point:

Academy Pilot TIE Fighter: 12 points, 2 attacks
Alpha Squad Pilot Tie Interceptor: 18 points, 3 attacks, Boost added to action bar

Both: Identical maneuver dials and stat lines with the exception of different K-Turns (the Interceptor can do 3/5-move ones and the TIE can do 3/4-move ones) and that one extra Attack.

Given that you aren't taking maneuver dials into play (and they are almost identical with the exception of K-Turns), that's a 6 point difference and the Engine Upgrade card that adds Boost to your bar is only 4 points which leaves a 2 point difference for that single extra attack. To me, this either shows your points worth value to potentially be undervaluing stat-line points or upgrade cards. What do you think?

Not that I'm trying to belittle your work here my friend, just trying to build on it. It took me since you posted this to even find this small of a thing, and you've done a great job. Any ideas for including the Large ships in this? The Decimator might throw a lot of this points value stuff out the window with its 12 Hull Points. There might be a different assigned value to certain attributes for Large ships vs. single pilot fighters.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Lost my old post, so here is the TL;DR version.

The Flight path and the Action Bar I always assumed is what differentiated the actual ships, otherwise each ship would be practically the same. I trust that the "Tank", "Wizard", "Bard", and "Paladin" are all by default different in their abilities, or lack thereof, is of any difference in base point cost (each start at zero) for games such as X-Wing or for 40k.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 · (Edited)
Update

Hey guys, for any of you all who have been interested in my creation earlier I have updated it with Scum, as well as the large ships.

If anyone has questions about anything feel free to ask me.
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top