Warhammer 40k Forum and Wargaming Forums banner

1 - 20 of 26 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Ok, let's see how this goes - hopefully well, and not devolve a bitch-fest.

Since I have publicly put out what changes I would make to 40k

I would like to hear what everyone's 5 least favorite things about their army is (feel free to do all of your armies). Also as a "play along" version your 5 least favorite things about the BRB (same rules)

For example;

Point Costs
Model/Unit Values (Wounds, Attacks, Armor Values, etc)
Special Rules
Wargear

Requirements:

This is Stuff strait from the Force Organization Chart / CAD Forces only - Keep your bitching about formations and that shit where they should be - at the bottom of a beer during a game of apocalypse.

Don't just give me a list of units and rules.

If a unit needs to be changed - tell me why it needs to be changed, and what changes would you make.

If a rule needs to be changed - Tell me verbatim what the current rule is, and why/what you would change.

I'm not psychic - I can't read minds (The other voices are happy with that) so please be as detailed as possible.

DETAILS DETAILS DETAILS

Feel free to PM me or reply to this thread, If possible I would like it if everyone that replies in the thread would attach their "complaints" as either a .PDF or a .TXT file (so that anyone can access them - no .Pages or .Doc or .Docx)

The attachments are mainly because it will be easier for me to keep things organized - so please do try to follow that request.

----

I will try to keep up with the thread as much as possible to keep people engaged.

*Crosses fingers that this goes as planned*

----

Thank you for reading, and a special thank you in advance if you decide to play along.
 

·
Entropy Fetishist
Joined
·
4,249 Posts
All right, of the codexes I own:

CSM:

1. Everything Mutilators. There are so many things wrong here, from points costs to funky weapons to various other shoddy things. To make them worthwhile, say... No scatter when DSing in and eliminate scatter on nearby DSing units within 6", or something. Plus having them be cheaper by 10-ish points.
2. Warp Talons. Able to assault the turn they DS, to reflect their "hunting a target through the warp then cutting their way into reality with their super-claws when they catch its warp-spoor." Some reliable way to eliminate scatter (and don't say "Dimensional Key," because I said "reliable") would also be nice, but see prior entry for a nice synergy option.
3. Daemon Prince. Simple change: give it Eternal Warrior back, and/or make it T6. I am so very frustrated with DPs that can get instagibbed by so many things in the game.
4. Thousand Sons. Change their Slow & Purposeful to Relentless for as long as their squad Sorc is alive; also make the squad Sorc 20-ish points cheaper, since he's 60 points for a crappy ML1 who rolls 1 crappy witchfire with a crappy combat statline and a force weapon you're paying full price on. And hell, make 1ksons 3 points cheaper per mini while you're at it.
5. Defiler. Either make it AV 13 13 11, like the cheaper-and-eminently-superior Soul Grinder, or make it at least 35 points cheaper (sure, strip out IWND and Daemonforge if you want to get fancy). Also, give it some way to be able to fire all its weapons without having to snap fire on the non-battle-cannon weapons (meaning it, as it stands, can't even fire its t-l heavy flamer/havoc launcher arm if it does use its cannon... or you have to spend a bunch of points on a funky melee weapon). Good grief, it needs an overhaul badly.


Those are some of the worst offenders, and the requested 5, but... good grief, there are so many more. Give Raptors some role that Bikers can't fill far better and more efficiently; rework the psychic powers so that each God has 6 available and Tzeentch's (you know, the god of magic's) powers are weird funky things with interesting synergy rather than crummy freaking witchfires; tweaking 4 or so of the Special Characters to do other things than "be a decent infantry fighter for 160-ish points"; fiddle with Possessed again, since they're still frustratingly underpowered--look at Wulfen for how they have the potential to be; reduce costs on (melee)Chosen, Berzerkers, Noise Marines and Plague Marines (at the very least) so they're fieldable; make Land Raiders cheaper and/or introduce another, much cheaper Assault Vehicle; add some viable AA apart from "crappy overpriced flakk missiles or a full-priced Helldrake with 4 S8 BS3 AP4 HAC shots"; revamp the 4 artifacts that nobody ever takes; overhaul the Dark Apostle to actually have a use...

I think you get the picture. I want to be done with this post some time tonight, and I have some other codexes to get to, so--moving on, sorry for not being more specific.

+++

Daemonkin:

1. Include Kharn.
2. Include Skarbrand.
3. Include Karanak.
4. Copy/paste some complaints from the CSM pile: cheaper Zerkers, rework Possession random bonuses, cheaper or tougher Defilers; a use for Raptors besides "in one formation."
5. Bloodcrushers. For the love of Khorne, give them T5 and a 3+ armor save. They might actually be worth their ridiculous price tag with those changes to their stats...

As a whole... Daemonkin compensates for the weaknesses of the Khorne elements of both its parent codexes quite well with the blood tithe mechanic, so no complaints there. More needs tweaking and tuning than a serious, major overhaul, as I see it.

+++

Daemons:

1. Bloodcrushers. The cat is already out of the gorebag, I suppose, so see above for Dr. Mossy's prescription.
2. Warpflame. Drop it entirely or change it to something benign, like "reroll Soul Blaze checks when the fire would be extinguished." That has the added benefit of making Soul Blaze not utterly junk.
3. Tzeentchi Witchfires. I know the leaked campaign supplement loads them up with a crapload more witchfires, yes, this isn't going to change, but... GW! Please! Policy change here, now, please!
4. Put Horrors back to being a shooting unit. We have enough Daemonology summoners and warp charge banks as it is, and Horrors are useless in combat and damn well nearly useless at range, these days. Also... I appreciate the spirit of the Blue Horrors rule, but change that to something actually useful (FNP 6+, or something) or cut it.
5. Tweak the Herald special characters so that you ever see them on the field--and while you're at it, count the Masque and the Blue Scribes as a Herald for FOC purposes. The Masque absolutely needs some sort of survivability, preferably making her actually be an independent character; Skulltaker needs AP2; Epidimius's tally mechanic needs to find a balance between it's brokenly-good-old and brokenly-awful-new settings; the Changeling needs some Callidus-esque nonsense rather than his fairly useless current abilities; and Karanak at the very least needs Rending, rather than AP-.

+++

I do also own Astra Militarum, but haven't really played them enough to have strong opinions on what ought to be changed, apart their codex generally being... slightly rather less powerful than the current codex creep curve.

I guess one concrete complaint is how Commissars have been made wholly obsolete by Priests, which cost half as many points and grant Zealot, which is a lot better than "summary execution on an officer for a rerolled Ld test." Make Commissars grant some other bonus, I say, that stacks with Zealot and possible orders. Rerolls to wound if you pass a priest-style exhortation test, perhaps, to pair with Zealot's Hatred? Or Preferred Enemy? Some way to make 6s in melee always wound on the squad, so that a mob of guardsmen can swamp a Wraithknight? I mean, the priest has several mini-orders it can attempt, so why not a Commissar to boot.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
129 Posts
Well, my office network is down, so time to trawl forums on my phone.

Righto,

Vanilla SMs:

1: Assault marines - I just really feel these don't deserve the name. I'd like to see maybe an extra attack or a reduced cost for the jump pack, but for me 3 WS4 S4 AP- attacks on the charge is rarely worth the 17 points. I play RG so these guys move into the usable category, but they rarely shine.

2: Normal Terminators: Assault terminators in a land raider are glorious, but their "shooty" cousins kick out a very underwhelming amount of firepower for their points cost. I'd like to see options for more special weapons in smaller squads, or maybe simply improved ballistic skill? I love the models, but these guys almost never make it into my list.

3. Honour Guard - Specifically the chapter champion. Either make him good in challenges or take that stupid forced challenge rule off him.

4. Where the hell is my Jump Pack command squad option?!

5. Characters. Iron Hands feel the burn here, why the hell should one chapter get SIX characters, whilst another first founding chapter gets zero? Lets do a quick break down of Codex: Ultramarines to point out the insanity.

Papa Smurf: No problems with Codex Ultramarines getting the only lord of war.

Capt. Sicarius: This is where my problems start. Lets count the number of C:SM characters that provide reserve modifiers. What's that? There's two!? And they're both SMURFS!? Bullshit.

Tigger: Here's the other reserve fairy, and the only ML3 Libby in in the book. If anyone should be getting an ML3 libby, it's White Scars.

Cassius: Tough as nails Chaplain? Salamanders or Iron Hands.

Telion; scout character? Frigging Raven Guard!

Chronos: This last one really takes the biscuit. Lets just ignore the vehicle orientated chapter with no characters when we make a specialist vehicle character, because Ultramarines need fancy land raiders!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
117 Posts
I totally agree with both posts above (especially @MossyToes, because Chaos is what I play and principally interested in since my come-back into the scene, but Space Marines are the ones I played before - Angels of Death and Ultramarines Codices of the 2nd Edition - and I therefore quite understand the lack of characters for other chapters than the Ultramarines).

The 5 things I think necessary to change regarding Chaos (mainly CSM, but with some close links to Daemons) are :

- The standardisation of the "Daemon" trait : the same wording and advantages for "Daemon" (CSM), "Daemonic Possession" (CSM), "Daemonforge" (CSM) and "Daemon of ..." (Daemons), including all of them being "Fearless" and replacing the "Ignore crew shaken" with the invulnerable save for vehicles (personnally, I would add "Eternal Warrior" to Greater Daemons and Daemon Princes only, but maybe give 2 Wounds for models which are hosting a daemon, like Possessed, Warp Talons, ...). And the possibility to buy "Daemonic Possession" on a Helbrute (just a detail compared to the rest, though).

- Lowering randomness : Chaos is entropy, and I'm not discussing it. But, even then, CSM and Daemons Codices play too much upon it compared to other armies (dice rolls for activating an artefact, for chaos boons, possessed advantage for the current turn, ...). That (too often) makes us roll dice to gain not-so-great-assets-compared-to-other-armies while taking the risk of seeing what has been paid for (and, sometimes, not for a cheap price) not only be unuseful, but also work against us. Paying so much for a possible +2 invul to one unit per turn with 1/3 chances to give it -1, or (amongst others) removing scatter for DS reserves only after CC kills are just a waste.

- Improving assault : Chaos is a CC oriented faction, but lacks of basic assault advantages, in matters like "offensive grenades" (Possessed, Warp Talons, Mutilators) and vehicles (just one, and an expensive one, for an assault oriented faction is not much enough). This can be done by adding Stormraven or Drop Pods equivalents, considering Rhinos as open-topped, ... and allowing CSM hosting a Daemon to keep their basic gear, for instance.

- Developing characters : some standard profiles (like the Dark Apostle or the Warpsmith) are far too limited to really be useful (except in very specific army lists). For named characters, the issue is basically the same as for Space Marines : a lot of them are missing (from the fluff or even from some profiles in the rules - talking about a named Dark Apostle with specific gear or abilities, for instance). Some of them, like Abaddon, should also be raised to Lords of War.

- And, finally, diversifying Chosen : these are supposed to be the elite (both into the fluff and the game) of a Legion/Warband, and they are limited to special weapons and a rhino. They should have access to different abilities and gear (jump packs, infiltration, tank hunters, daemons, ...).

I don't know whether GW is planning to provide us with a new version of the CSM Codex (it's probably not a waste to invest into CSM for a brand new release in a 2 or 3 years term), but it also seems useful to handle the short term. And, within the current system, this can rather easily be done through Detachments and Formations (giving special rules for particular organizational charts without directly modifying the Codex). I have made my personal attempt on this ( http://www.heresy-online.net/forums/showthread.php?t=199002 ), and I'm not the only one.

It could be a quick way for GW to patch things (not only for the CSM, even if they are amongst the few factions which have the fewest Detachments/Formations of the game) while working upon a new Codex at the mid/long term.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
326 Posts
Well, my office network is down, so time to trawl forums on my phone.

Righto,

Vanilla SMs:

1: Assault marines - I just really feel these don't deserve the name. I'd like to see maybe an extra attack or a reduced cost for the jump pack, but for me 3 WS4 S4 AP- attacks on the charge is rarely worth the 17 points. I play RG so these guys move into the usable category, but they rarely shine.

2: Normal Terminators: Assault terminators in a land raider are glorious, but their "shooty" cousins kick out a very underwhelming amount of firepower for their points cost. I'd like to see options for more special weapons in smaller squads, or maybe simply improved ballistic skill? I love the models, but these guys almost never make it into my list.

3. Honour Guard - Specifically the chapter champion. Either make him good in challenges or take that stupid forced challenge rule off him.

4. Where the hell is my Jump Pack command squad option?!

5. Characters. Iron Hands feel the burn here, why the hell should one chapter get SIX characters, whilst another first founding chapter gets zero? Lets do a quick break down of Codex: Ultramarines to point out the insanity.

Papa Smurf: No problems with Codex Ultramarines getting the only lord of war.

Capt. Sicarius: This is where my problems start. Lets count the number of C:SM characters that provide reserve modifiers. What's that? There's two!? And they're both SMURFS!? Bullshit.

Tigger: Here's the other reserve fairy, and the only ML3 Libby in in the book. If anyone should be getting an ML3 libby, it's White Scars.

Cassius: Tough as nails Chaplain? Salamanders or Iron Hands.

Telion; scout character? Frigging Raven Guard!

Chronos: This last one really takes the biscuit. Lets just ignore the vehicle orientated chapter with no characters when we make a specialist vehicle character, because Ultramarines need fancy land raiders!
Man, this is spot on. I tried getting into SM but am not interested in Ultramarine so I felt had no options. Most SM units are almost identical to each other, which is kinda boring. The units that were different enough to be interesting either cost too much or were a named Ultramarine character.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,459 Posts
The first thought that comes to mind is:

Dark Angels:
If your Company Master is equipped with terminator armor: terminators as troops, if he's on a bike: ravenwing units as troops. Or maybe even Interrogator chaplains get either as troops.

This is the main glaring "issue" I have with the Codex's I own. Not super important, but in my opinion, important enough. Having the characters as requirements just does not cut it for me. They're way too taxing in points.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,459 Posts
Nothing really makes me NEED to, but having the "x allows you to take y as troops" option still available is just a trope I always like (i am a csm player and i felt that that option made the book fairly unique). Just felt it was a concept that was under utilized before formations came about.

Tl;dr living in the past
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
10,978 Posts
Okay, first up will be tyranids.

1: The carnifex. What is it even there for anymore? It's an all rounder not as good in cc as the other monsters, and not as good at range or support as the tyrant or tyrannofex. It is just as fragile as the other monsters, maybe even moreso due to the lower than most wound count. I'm okay with it being an all rounder, really. But if that's going to be the case then it needs to be tougher, more resilient, it needs to have its own selling point that makes it worth considering after the trygon or exocrine. Bring back its T7, W5 and 2+ armour save. If it can't be more dangerous than the other monsters, it should at least be more resilient. A near unkillable monster as it is in the fluff.

2: The venom cannon. There was a time this fired three shots and wasn't blast. It needs to be this again, if only for the sake of the harpy and flyrant so they can be viable anti air units against things like stormravens. The crone is just too unreliable.

3: Lictors. They need to be able to assault off the turn they deep strike again. Forcing them to use the standard DS and Infiltrate rules makes them useless. Or give them their own rule to reflect their ambush attacks.

4: The Tyranid Prime. It's supposed to be a cheaper alternative to a hive tyrant and yet it is still too overpriced for its vanilla build and options. I would like to see it a little more diverse, maybe not restricted to just being a tyranid warrior. For example:

Lictor Prime, have the prime be a lictor with access to infiltration and stealth rules.
Ravener Prime, the prime is a ravener with faster movement and Hammer of Wrath.
Shrike Prime, self explanatory. Let the prime have the option for wings.
Zoanthrope Prime, give the prime options to be a psyker.
Venomthrope Prime, the prime has access to potent poison attacks and defensive rules.

5: Psykers. I'd like to see tyranid psykers once more have access to Biomancy and Telepathy. Being restricted to their own disciplines is too limiting, and they're supposed to be more adaptive than that.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 · (Edited)
Keep your bitching about formations and that shit where they should be - at the bottom of a beer during a game of apocalypse.
I'm just reposting this here - not calling anyone out (and sorry @ntaw for you being right behind this you were just the first to mention stuffs) but I don't give 2 fucks about formations and fixing said formations because my "answer" would be to just get rid of all that shit (along with Lords of War - since I think it's stupid as fuck for a character to be one), and put it in an apocalypse book.

Which is the entire reason why I asked you guys to NOT include anything about formations for me

1. Formations that are even remotely useful.
Dark Angels:
If your Company Master is equipped with terminator armor: terminators as troops, if he's on a bike: ravenwing units as troops. Or maybe even Interrogator chaplains get either as troops.
now in 7th ed, you need a formation to run them. I am talking regular FOC rules
What makes you need to play a Combined Arms Detachment?
*cough* read 1st post :eek:k: *cough* as that is the entire reason behind this.

Tl;dr living in the past
:good:

@Einherjar667 I'll just let you know that a generic character for the DA won't unlock an entire unit as troops; Probably just 1 (or 2...IDK?) DW for a dude in termie armor, 2 RW for a dude on a bike, and 1 of each for a Interrogator Chaplain. So there's that, besides that "thought" I haven't worked on them yet - been doing IRL Work, and I'm starting with @Mossy Toes and working down. (Fuck Mutilators:headbutt:)

Because besides that I think that the leaders of those factions (+ Azreal(?)) will be the only way to unlock the entire bunch - because as far as I recall those "factions" within the DA don't mix with the plebs (Green Wing) too much. The Named Characters will probably get a tweak as well.

----

@Rush Darling I'll also let you know that I'm not going to fuck with the NAMES and BACKSTORIES of named characters from Vanilla Marines - might tweak their points, but as far as I am concerned that's something you can model up yourself and "Count As" that shit.

----

I'll do my best to release updates on Sundays and/or Wednesdays. Probably just once a week, It'll take longer for certain armies since I will need to borrow Codexes from friends ( @Serpion5 & @Rush Darling Your 'Nids & SMs are here)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Point taken, posts removed. Enjoy your thread :eek:k:

I had a longer post than this with some explanation but Heresy likes dicking with my posts these days, so yeah.
The rest of your post was valid, no reason to delete - it's just that Formations are something that I do not wish to try to attempt to tackle due to my own bias against them. There are many other, probably smarter, people who are able to take that into consideration.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
959 Posts
Only a few come to mind and its all for Necrons. Bear with me on this:

NECRONS:

Tesseract Vault: Make it like it used to be when you could purchase what powers it could use or reduce the price. Right now, you are paying the equivalent of 11 Killa-kans for a vehicle that has random shooting powers that may or may not be useful. Simply put, when compared to something like a Knight or the Wraithknight, it just feels lacking at that price given that you are at the mercy of a D6 roll for your power that turn.

Obelisk: Not as lacking as the Vault but could do with a slight price reduction. Or possibly the ability to act as a teleport homer.

Scarabs: I see no reason for their price to increase by 5pts each, especially since they can't eat vehicles as easily as their last codex.Bring the points back down to their original.

Anrakyr: Took a huge hit this edition since Mind in the Machine randomly picks a single weapon on a vehicle to fire. Simply revert it to how it was or allow the player to pick the weapon fired.

Annhilation Barges: Given the (justified) nerf to Tesla, there isn't as much reason for their current point cost since they can't jink and still score 12 hits anymore. Knock it down to 100 pts each and we're good.


Probably have more for my other codexes but I'm tired.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Ok, here are some of everyone's changes - mostly focused on CSM and Demons since I have those Codexs on hand - also do note that this does include the changes that I would make to the BRB

Looking to see if I can borrow a friends Vanilla Marines, Tyranids, Necrons, or DA codex.

----

Also if @ntaw is still lurking around, I do wish that you had not deleted your post since I was interested in seeing what your BA wish list was - If you wish to PM me and discuss it privately I can do that if you wish.

----

Note: for the BRB errata/FAQ/Changes I will put the same Disclaimer here as I put in the other thread I linked to in my OP, please PLEASE read it over very carefully and have your BRB out with you when you do - there are a lot of minute changes/clarifications (LoS!) and real potential game changers (Over watch)
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
@Tyriks Absolutely not, add away my friend.

But please, don't ask for anything regarding formations.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,689 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
sorry for delay been waiting for some codexs to be freed up from their owners...and being sick for a week or so.

----

anyways, I hope that everyone is enjoying this little event (and if you wish to talk/argue/debate some of the things that I have posted regarding these house-rules.

----

To continue - I have received the SM and Nid codex yesterday (Tuesday) and I have been quietly rambling on.

The first thing I shall post is the Tyranid "Shadow in the warp" change I made, since... it...it's hard to create a suitable rule change and have it work and still be fluffy.

I kinda wanted to post it here first before I officially add it to my word/pdf file.

----

TYRANIDS
Shadow in the Warp: Rewrite
All enemy unit, and or models, with the “Psycher”, “Psychic Pilot”, or “Brotherhood of Psychers” special rule attempting to cast a psychic power against a unit from the “Tyranid Faction” it suffers a negative 1 penalty to its Leadership value. In addition, should the Psycher be within 12” of a Tyranid with the “Synapse creature” special rule it suffers an additional negative 1 penalty.

Synapse Creature: Amendment
Add “In addition, models with this rule count as being a Mastery Level 1 Psycher for Deny The Witch rolls only; should the model have a Mastery Level higher than 1 it is treated as having its original value.”

----

I have been brooding on how I would change this rule, and I wanted to get some feedback on it first.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,195 Posts
Orks:
Mob Rule should go back to what it was before or some variation of that. This ties into the next part.

Trukks should be cheaper if not free for various units. Right now if you take a unit of boys in a trukk with no eavy armor and it explodes the chance of mob rule screwing you over is extremely high. 35 points (40 if your take the ram too) for a 10 all around open topped transport is a hefty chunk of points if you try to run a trukk list.

My current 1850 list has 3 trukks with 12 boys in it. I put them all in eavy armor because of the mob rule and trukk combo. That is about 249 points for the armor and trukks, 264 if i added rams.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
10,978 Posts
TYRANIDS

Shadow in the Warp: Rewrite All enemy unit, and or models, with the “Psycher”, “Psychic Pilot”, or “Brotherhood of Psychers” special rule attempting to cast a psychic power against a unit from the “Tyranid Faction” it suffers a negative 1 penalty to its Leadership value. In addition, should the Psycher be within 12” of a Tyranid with the “Synapse creature” special rule it suffers an additional negative 1 penalty.

Synapse Creature: Amendment Add “In addition, models with this rule count as being a Mastery Level 1 Psycher for Deny The Witch rolls only; should the model have a Mastery Level higher than 1 it is treated as having its original value.”
I think it would be simpler to state that synapse creatures benefit from Adamantium Will.

Have Shadow in the Warp force enemy psykers to re-roll sixes when casting powers in proximity.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
129 Posts
Have Shadow in the Warp force enemy psykers to re-roll sixes when casting powers in proximity.
When they're trying to harness? Wouldn't that just help them avoid perils? Maybe make them re-roll 4s?

Making them re-roll sixes whilst trying to deny however would be somewhat helpful. Kind of the opposite of GKs Aegis.

EDIT: I'll take pretty much any change to the current rule, as right now it's so very meh.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
10,978 Posts
When they're trying to harness? Wouldn't that just help them avoid perils? Maybe make them re-roll 4s?
I think re-rolling successful warp charges is a bit overkill. Re-rolling sixes still gives a chance to fail. Also since the Shadow is described as blanking an area of the warp in fluff, it is less likely for perils to take hold anyway.
 
1 - 20 of 26 Posts
Top