Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums - Reply to Topic
Black Library Fiction Here is where you can discuss your favourite Black Library publications and graphic novels. If it's published by Black Library it goes here.

Thread: Dark Imperium - Guy Haley Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in










  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
08-10-17 07:30 PM
Brother Dextus
Quote:
Originally Posted by Khorne's Fist View Post
McNeill is as hit-and-miss as Hayley. Some fantastic books, like A Thousand Sons and the Priests of Mars series, as well as dross like The Outcast Dead and the Uriel Ventris books.
I guess this sort of prooves you cant please everyone - i really liked the Ventris ones (but mainly because he was a goddam ass for most of it)

Thousand sons was pretty good IMO, but not read the Mars ones.
08-10-17 05:19 PM
Entarion
Quote:
Originally Posted by Knockagh View Post
The longer I read BL I realise I like marines in small doses as super heros who appear (briefly) to save the day or in the case of chaos marines ruin someone's day. But can't have a whole book focused on them.
I totally agree with you. It's a huge difference when space marines are in IG or Inquisitor novel. Good example is Vaults of Terra. Scenes with Custodes are majestic. I recently noticed that I am quite bored by regular SM action and I definitely not read that many books.
08-10-17 05:10 PM
Khorne's Fist
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brother Dextus View Post
If McNeil had done some of these newer books I can see there would be a slightly different tone to the conversations on here and other forums.
McNeill is as hit-and-miss as Hayley. Some fantastic books, like A Thousand Sons and the Priests of Mars series, as well as dross like The Outcast Dead and the Uriel Ventris books.
08-10-17 08:34 AM
Brother Dextus My first books were Eisenhorn/ravenor, Gaunt and Cain.... all non marine ones, with characters I really loved, they had substance! From Jurgen with his endless cups of recaf for cain, to try again bragg who i literally shed a tear for!


The Heresy books have been good, some great ones, but most are good. Ive only read the iron warriors/ultramarines omnibus, and the armageddonADB 40k marine books because i keep hearing about the lack of character in a lot of the marine focussed books. Guy Haley isn't the best i must say, but he seems to have a good contact at GW and they keep selecting him to do more writing.


If McNeil had done some of these newer books I can see there would be a slightly different tone to the conversations on here and other forums.
08-09-17 09:23 PM
Knockagh @Shandathe, couldn't agree more on the importance of characters and ongoing character development to bring about fan attachment to the books.
I think they have realised this to a degree with the new inquisitor covenant storyline and abd's black legion series or the shadowsword/baneblade books.
But they seem convinced that the majority of BL readers want plenty of lengthy battle scenes with little character development. This or simply it's just easier to produce vast amounts of this type of story. BL have a fairly relentless release schedule and that's never a good thing for quality.
There have also been some amazing stand alone books of recent which haven't focused on space marines and explosions. Jain Zar, Lorgar and the vaults of terra have been, I think, amazing.
I found Dark Imperium so disappointing as it seemed a throw back to poorer rushed works with bland uninteresting characters. Guy is a great author so I will let this one slide!
08-09-17 09:03 PM
Shandathe It's just especially obvious in Space Marine books. We're getting battles just because the book should have fighting in it, rather than because they advance the plot or affect the people involved in a meaningful way... Well, they might, but we never get to KNOW the people so what's the point.

The problem with BL is that they don't seem to realize that books should be about CHARACTERS. People, not just fighting. You'd think it would be obvious with long-running series like Cain and Gotrek & Felix... Much like those, the good Marine books manage to get plot advancement, character interaction and/or development in during the fight scenes. Obvious example from James Swallow's Blood Angel books, Dante and Gabriel Seth fighting side by side.

Mediocre ones - and I'm counting Dark Imperium among those - only manage it in between. Guy Haley makes a brave attempt at it, but he's stuck with an ensemble cast that needs screen time on everyone. The apparently mandatory number of battle scenes largely turns into meaningless interpunction that can be skipped without missing anything. The book is (IMO) at it's best during the character focus scenes - Calgar's musings, a squad of Primaris marines just chillaxing and highlighting the marines of various legions coming together, Guilliman's interactions with the Cawl Inferior, Typhus telling Mortarion what's what.
08-09-17 07:45 PM
Knockagh First Guy Haley book I didn't enjoy. Some moments of brightness but otherwise a fairly dull marine book. After the wonder he pulled off with Dante I was pretty disappointed.
There's so much I'm enjoying from BL at the minute probably made this book seem even poorer.
The longer I read BL I realise I like marines in small doses as super heros who appear (briefly) to save the day or in the case of chaos marines ruin someone's day. But can't have a whole book focused on them.
08-09-17 03:24 PM
Brother Dextus Thanks for those, i guess I'm up to speed now.... will go read the next couple of books and see what girlyman does.
08-07-17 06:41 PM
Haskanael
Rise of the Primarch.

and the last one from the Dakka Dakka post.



08-07-17 06:38 PM
Haskanael
Fracture of Biel-Tan

and again from the Dakka Dakka post
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome