|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|11-01-14 06:28 PM|
|ChaosRedCorsairLord||Yeah, definitely the way to go.|
|11-01-14 04:21 PM|
|Moriouce||Good call Dave!|
|10-31-14 04:06 PM|
|Dave T Hobbit||
Thank you to everyone who commented, and for the polite manner in which you expressed your opinions.
Well, I think everyone who wanted to has had time to comment, so I am making a decision.
Spending time doing something makes you better at it, whether or not you are being paid.
In addition, any definition of professional is always going to be an arbitrary line somewhere between never having painted a miniature for another person and only painting miniatures in exchange for money.
So, the monthly deathmatches will remain open to members who might count as professionals in that aspect of the hobby, but voters can choose to take the career into account if they feel it is relevant.
|10-08-14 09:29 AM|
|Belovoj||simple opinion from me: the better my opponents in competitions are, the more pleasure from entering and competing them I have. there will always be a difference between skill levels and IMHO that's the point of competition - to try to get better then everybody else :D it would be too easy if everybody was the same skill level at the beginning ;)|
|10-07-14 05:03 PM|
|Dave T Hobbit||
Originally Posted by Kreuger View Post
For me, they aren't about who is objectively best. They are about having an opportunity to push yourself to your limits in search of a better model or story. To say I think this is good work and am not afraid to put it to the test.
The rules of each competition are equally broad on what is good work: the Painting Deathmatch includes 'improvement' as a possible criteria, so someone could chose to vote for an entrant because they did wet blending for the first time; the Conversion Deathmatch awards equal honour to having a cool idea as it does to skill.
|10-07-14 09:56 AM|
Originally Posted by DeathKlokk View Post
|10-07-14 02:30 AM|
|Ring Master "Honka"||
I will admit at times i have thought that there is no point in me entering because of pros. but that means not entering now because i need to get better, sometimes i paint something and think "hey yeah that's good" then i see what awesome things people create on here and realise shit i need to do better. so i go into the painting section and lookup any hints and tips from the pros then proceed to try and better myself.
then i make a horrible mess and drink a lot.... or the other way round
if i got 1 or 2 votes in the painting challenge. i would appreciate it more if i got them when there are pros entering because im on my way to matching up. if i won because all the other entries had decided to drink there paints rather then use them it wouldn't feel so good.
if we remove pro painters from the challenges then we are penalising people because they are good which is pointless
|10-07-14 02:07 AM|
I haven't partaken of any of the comps because of time, but I do like looking to see what cool things everyone what is doing.
Before commenting on this I re-read the rules for the conversion death match. I think the inestimable Mr. Klokk has his finger on the real question, "What is the intent of these competitions?"
Clearly, the simplest interpretation of the intent is to encourage forum participation. And perhaps it's fair to say the secondary goal is to encourage and recognize the growing skills in our community. So, is that end served better by allowing ringers/pros to compete with the hobbyists?
It seems to me that as long as the pros (whoever they are) aren't let loose to run roughshod over everyone else then their skills and contributions add luster to the competition.
Based on the comp rules this isn't necessarily a problem.
Originally Posted by from the rules View Post
|10-07-14 02:00 AM|
Oh man, if I had to learn how I paint without the internet I would have taken eons to improve. Even just my interactions on this site have been invaluable to my growing skill and confidence.
You have some awesome work posted up on that site DeathKlokk, I particularly like the Banshees and Death Jester.
|10-07-14 01:33 AM|
Thanks, Tawa and RedCorsair.
I agree Oldman. The fact that people get paid to paint doesn't make them that much better to make it unfair IMHO.
Ntaw, keep entering the comps, regardless of the level of competition. You don't get better by competing against shitty competition. You'll improve over time. I've been painting minis for longer than a lot of you guys have been alive and most of that time was without the tremendous amount of information at hand that there is nowadays. I still learn something new with almost every miniature I do.
I don't have a ton of stuff online anymore but my CMoN page is Here for those interested.
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|