Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums - Reply to Topic
40k Fluff Discuss GW background material here. All those bits in the Codex that aren't stat blocks or special rules. Post your custom character/chapter/army background in our Homebrew Fluff subforum!

Thread: Imperial knights reload? Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now



In order to be able to post messages on the Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:
OR

Log-in










  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
04-06-14 10:06 PM
doofyoofy Fair enough. Thanks for that.
04-06-14 07:14 AM
Rems
Quote:
Originally Posted by doofyoofy View Post
Thank you for the reply. Forgive me, I believe I was unclear in my original post. I mean specifically reloading the battle cannon after each shot. Is it magazine fed which i think would be the box behind the gunshield?

if so it doesnt seem like that magazine would hold enough rounds for even 3 or 4 shots, if it is a magazine then the above would apply. Due to the calibre of battle cannon though it seems like it might be a reload after everyshot in which case where does the ammo come from and how does it get to the weapon?

It would seem unlikely that they have to go to their resupply station after every shot...
Yea it's the box behind the shield. Assuming each shell is smaller than the smallest part of the barrel then it actually looks like you could fit a few in the box, certainly more than 1.

This comes down to an issue of scale and artistic representation. The models are not supposed to be exactly scale accurate. Look at the Space Marine rhino, you can't fit 10 tactical marines in that yet we know in the fluff it can.

Assume that in the fluff yes the Paladin does carry more than one round, that it can reload via an automatic feed.
04-04-14 12:55 PM
locustgate
Quote:
Originally Posted by hailene View Post
Go back 3000 years (or heck, *300* years) and say we could build 120+ story buildings and they'd laugh at you. The means and materials just weren't available back then*.

*Okay, maybe they were? I don't know, I'm no pre-industrial revolution historian. Still, the point stands. With sufficient technology, anything is possible. We know that the Imperium has access to some fantastically durable, malleable metals or alloys (thanks to the likes of Terminator armor), so is it so far-fetched they'd apply them to their walkers and titans?
Both architect and materials were not there and lets be honest who in the world would walk 120 stories worth of stairs everyday?
04-04-14 05:59 AM
doofyoofy I understand, similar to how the leman model has a ginormous cannon and a super small turret, however that can at least be applied to it has super special materials or wat have u.
This is not the case with the imperial knight where it appears to just be the weapon and recoil with maybe a magazine behind the gunshield. The subcalibre thing could be plausible, but its stated to be a battlecannon which tends mean at least leman russ cannon size which means min of 120 mm cannon. So unless they have teleport technology then it can only fire 4 rounds without some kind of reload.
Just because its a model doesnt mean it at least cant be semi plausible with "future" tech and materials, i.e. similar to the Leman russ, or thunderbolt etc.
04-04-14 04:54 AM
Jolnir
Quote:
Originally Posted by hailene View Post
Meh, if they were made of materials known to us at the moment.

If they were made of a stronger material...or a lighter material or some lesser combination of both? Possible. Maybe reinforced by some process unknown to us.

Go back 3000 years (or heck, *300* years) and say we could build 120+ story buildings and they'd laugh at you. The means and materials just weren't available back then*.

*Okay, maybe they were? I don't know, I'm no pre-industrial revolution historian. Still, the point stands. With sufficient technology, anything is possible. We know that the Imperium has access to some fantastically durable, malleable metals or alloys (thanks to the likes of Terminator armor), so is it so far-fetched they'd apply them to their walkers and titans?
Oh, I know. This is a game with imagination and fantasy. I was merely stating that you can't expect every aspect of the tech in 40k to make perfect sense from mo0dern tech's perspective. Think lightsabres and blaster pistols from Star Wars...
04-04-14 01:04 AM
hailene
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jolnir View Post
If we were applying reality to 40k models, then all of the "walkers" would probably not be able to walk. Their legs and hydraulic mechanisms would not support their massive structures. It is all about imagination.
Meh, if they were made of materials known to us at the moment.

If they were made of a stronger material...or a lighter material or some lesser combination of both? Possible. Maybe reinforced by some process unknown to us.

Go back 3000 years (or heck, *300* years) and say we could build 120+ story buildings and they'd laugh at you. The means and materials just weren't available back then*.

*Okay, maybe they were? I don't know, I'm no pre-industrial revolution historian. Still, the point stands. With sufficient technology, anything is possible. We know that the Imperium has access to some fantastically durable, malleable metals or alloys (thanks to the likes of Terminator armor), so is it so far-fetched they'd apply them to their walkers and titans?
04-03-14 08:09 PM
Jolnir If we were applying reality to 40k models, then all of the "walkers" would probably not be able to walk. Their legs and hydraulic mechanisms would not support their massive structures. It is all about imagination.
04-03-14 07:49 PM
Old Man78 I see where you are comming from, but remember it is a sci fi mini not a scale model of an actual war machine, it is sculpted more to look good than fuctional, as to your question the rounds may be quite small literally the warhead with very small casing or no casing with a solid propellant with the warhead embedded in it, after all it is the 41st millenium an propellant charges are probably a lot more powerfull than what we be used to seeing in our own reality.

Also militeries tend to assault suppress reserve, with units attacking others giving cover and otherscin reserve reloading sorting themselves out getting ready to go again
04-03-14 06:15 PM
doofyoofy Thank you for the reply. Forgive me, I believe I was unclear in my original post. I mean specifically reloading the battle cannon after each shot. Is it magazine fed which i think would be the box behind the gunshield?

if so it doesnt seem like that magazine would hold enough rounds for even 3 or 4 shots, if it is a magazine then the above would apply. Due to the calibre of battle cannon though it seems like it might be a reload after everyshot in which case where does the ammo come from and how does it get to the weapon?

It would seem unlikely that they have to go to their resupply station after every shot...
04-03-14 09:17 AM
Rems They would resupply mid 'battle', much like Titans do, or other armoured vehicles. Depending on distance they would resupply at arming stations and ammo dumps or have it brought to them. Remember they're not deployed on their lonesome, there's a whole mechanicus and feudal bondsman support network behind them.

Each Paladin would carry enough munitions for an engagement and then return to rearm. Realise that a battle is not continuous fighting everywhere at once. Think more of a series of firefights and clashes than one long brawl.
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome