|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|11-04-11 02:13 PM|
Originally Posted by Bubblematrix View Post
|11-04-11 02:05 PM|
|Jace of Ultramar||
Originally Posted by jaysen View Post
In regards to iconography, is the arrow on the right pad necessary?
|11-04-11 01:12 PM|
|jaysen||It is fine to have several different chapters in one space marine army, as long as they are all from the same codex. If they are well-painted, and look to be the same army, they will do well. For example, each squad have an army badge in addition to their chapter colors and iconagraphy. Also, ensure all the squads have similar basing that ties the army together.|
|11-03-11 02:34 PM|
Personally I think that look, composition, colour etc has about as much place in final tournament rankings as favourite sports team - I don't play tournaments but if I did then I would get pissed that I may rank lower than someone just because they smiled at their oponents jokes and had an army they bought nicely painted for them.
Put those in a seperate category, have a sportsmans and best painted army award but they should be kept out of rankings imo.
As for different chapters in the same army, I would suggest that these kinds of scoring systems will favour you more for a single chapter army all painted in continuous colour scheme - in most cases it simply looks better.
|11-03-11 02:03 PM|
|Jace of Ultramar||
Appearance & Composition @ tourneys
Just a quick question on the topic of appearance & composition for an army at a tourney.
I was at my LGS last night and a friend of mine was talking to me about past tournaments he held at his store and how every now and then someone would absolutely complain about how they had the best painted squad, won all their games, and yet didn't come in first. Usually, he said, the individual would not have flocked the base or something to that effect and that they would ask random customers to pick their 5 favourite armies rating them from 1-5, thus preventing the store from having a biased opinion due to it being a random person's rating on appearance. He and another person would take these results and determine ranking with them. He also explained to me that this was but a percentage of an overall scoring that had to do with sportsmanship and other things.
Which brings me to the question of; is it acceptable to have more than one chapter represented in an army? I'm primarily building a Crimson Fist army but happen to have about 10 Ultramarines, painted as such due to the shoulder pads having the moulded U on it, and Telion. In the SM codex, right before unit stats, there is a grey box discussing that not all the following units are from the same chapter and having more than one chapter represented can signify cooperation between two chapters. Is this acceptable on a tourney level? I'd like to know seeing as how I've already painted the Ultramarines and Telion to their specifications.