|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|10-27-11 07:14 AM|
This may sound odd compared to all the other mentioned units ....but.
I wish chosen could be better. The only reason I say this is the simple fact they are the linchpin of my army, but hardly come off as veterans and aspiring chaos lords that they are made out to be. Also a lot of the wargear options are restrictively high this late in the game. really 50pts for 2 static pf attacks? Also all the heavy weapons are just as over coasted as for devastators and havocks. Seriously, these days most armies feer auto cannons and bright lances more then a las cannon.
Mind you I would like if they at least had the option to come bare bones like they do with a veteran skill, as I like the role they offer as a mobile assault weapons platform, but they really should have had the option to chose/buy their veteran skill as all chosen getting infiltrate makes very little sense. Example: Are you saying my Khoranate chosen with giant ass bulky CC weapons are masters of stealth, and recon?
Also I am well aware that many other units of greater import are much more in need of revision, but I thought I would mention my woes over chosen do to the fact that I spent 40+ hours building/painting my 25+ strong urban commando style chosen. Who come complete with urban camo patches and gas masks, and a absurd amount of assault weapons.
|10-27-11 05:56 AM|
|10-27-11 04:01 AM|
Eradicator and Punisher variants of the Leman Russ
I wish Commissars/Lord Commissars could be of any use in a mechanized army, but they're just great for blobs and that's it. I purchased a Lord Commissar model because I love him so much, but I have almost no intent on using him.
Ogryns are overpriced for what they do, Ratlings are just... not worthwhile
|10-25-11 12:58 PM|
Possessed and Raptors, although I've heard of success stories with both. I don't like the idea of Raptors being seen as second-rate tank poppers when there's an entire cult based on them. They deserve more dammit!
I also wish that the Chaos Bikers, Thousand Sons and Noise marines costed less points. I actually like Noise marines and the Thousand sons, but I simply think that the bikers cost too much. I don't actually like them that much.
|10-25-11 01:17 AM|
I never said that the kroot didn't find a place in the codex, or even that I didn't like them the way they are. Personally it would make me sad to see them as anything but a rapid-firing infiltration squad that dies when glanced at. It's how I like them. But I can see why people want them to be better.
They have a fairly decent fluff and had some great rulesets that made them shine on their own. They get a lot of credit in the books and I know in Rogue Trader it is my favorite class to play as. (Altough my GM refuses to let us run xenos characters often)
They could be a lot better if they were allowed decent upgrades. Keep the base cost the same but with a shaper, hopefully at a decent price, can give the unit upgrades to make them more than just a sacrificial lamb even with raising unit cost.
But with most things wrong with the Tau codex, it's basically too little options at too high of a price.
|10-25-11 01:04 AM|
Originally Posted by SavageConvoy View Post
They are very good at what they do... now if you want them to be a dedicated, winning close combat unit, then they have a long way to go and would easily cost two, three times as much.
So they are a good unit. When compared to other things that fill no role, or have another unit that does it so much better (stealthsuits, sniper drones, gun drone squadron, skyray), the kroot really do shine as a good investment that remains relevant to 5th, which is saying something for this codex.
Oh, and Ravenwing squadrons need a rework to not bleed kill-points, and deathwing need a cost reduction.
|10-25-11 12:24 AM|
|SavageConvoy||They may be cheap but with no armor, low I, and LD7 they fall apart like mad. They just can't dish out wounds and take too many in return. Assault weapons or even the old genetic buffs they used to get would be great. But right now they get put on the field for the sole purpose of getting killed.|
|10-24-11 03:58 PM|
Originally Posted by HUMYN HYBRID View Post
|10-24-11 03:50 PM|
40k too? Awesome. So,
Death Co with packs. Its just a waste. They are so easy to mess up its not even funny
Swooping Hawks. They arent good enough for how cool they are
Warp Spiders. See above
The entire Tau Army. They are awesome, but they are terrible in game
-Specifically Fire Warriors and Stealth Teams
Scouts. They should have higher bs/ws. They did in g3 and that was awesome
yeah... thats all i can think of now but will probably post later
*EDIT* Oh yeah... Kroot. Not very good, 3 scouts killed 12 out of 16 of them and the rest retreated. 2 scouts died.
|10-24-11 03:46 PM|
|HUMYN HYBRID||im a massive tau player, and i highly dislike close combat, but when it comes to assaulting, the kroot just seem to drop like flies when being shot at. i reckon they should get at least some kind of armour save, but what would make them even deadlier... if they were assault troops, not rapid fire. otherwise you have to choose between shooting an army down, or assaulting, i mean, with that kind of power they have now, it is a better choice, in case of an assault trap, but i have not run into that kind of situation. ther kroot are very agile, and very strong, i dont see why they cant shot an enemy down, then assault the survivors. they would be much more effective, and also, the ethereals. they could be changed a bit so that my army isnt insta-killed when i decide to field them. maybe allow normal ethereals to have body guards like aunva, cus they just hammer if they get close enough.|
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|