Originally Posted by normtheunsavoury
There's your problem right there.
You work in a top 40 nightclub meaning the music played is the lowest common denominator mass produced drivel. In the same way as most mainstream metal is horrible, piss weak nonsense that lacks any form of real musical merit, mainstream urban music is the same. Rap music is just different, its not any better or worse other than in your personal taste. Music will always be a subjective thing, personal taste is how we select music that we like, we don't choose music on merit.
Using machines to make music isn't necessarily a bad thing either, I love trip hop as well as metal, bands like Massive Attack, Sneaker Pimps or Portishead wouldn't exist if not for some very clever music software and hardware. I also like a lot of industrial stuff, Godflesh use drum machines, GGFH use synths and all sorts of strange equipment and so do KMFDM, they don't sing about hoes and money though so does that make them more or less valid in your opinion?
As long as music provokes a feeling or emotion in the listener then it has done its job, it is a form of artistic expression and musicians will always produce music that is relevant and meaningful to them. If that means hoes and bitches and selling drugs then fair enough, it doesn't particularly appeal to me but I wouldn't say it was any less relevant than the music I listen to about serial killers, suicide, black magic, Satanism or warfare.
It could just be the punk in me but I can't stand the idea that you need to be a virtuoso to play music, that you somehow need to be a master of a particular musical instrument to be relevant. If you can make something make a noise then you can make music, if that something happens to be a drum machine and a sampler then go for it, make your music. The end result may not be to my taste, it doesn't have to be, as long as you like it that's all that matters.
On that note, I will leave you with a short blast of fucked up weird industrial music that I love.
im going to work down this as necessary, but i hope you get the point im trying to make on this.
Rap / hip-hop, by definition is usually a single artist SPEAKING RHYMES to a set beat, yes? Music, by definition on the other hand is a series of notes played on instruments to create a melody, which usually has intros, verses, endings, the lyrics dont always rhyme, but usually they are sung, changing the word from how we normally speak it to fit in better with the Melody behind it.
Rap / hip-hop does NOT fit into a musical category, it fits far closer into a poetry category, and some artists I have a respect for, AS POETS, but not as musicians.
I can rhyme till the sun dont shine,
and if you think me a liar, then im gunna set you on fire.
I can rhyme stupidly easy, I can make a beat and rhyme to it stupidly easy, there is no skill involved in rhyming off another persons beat. I will respect them as music when I see them doing their thing while, at the very least, having somneone behind them playing the melody they are rapping / hip-hoping to.
to bring up the thoughts of industrial music, the music itsself is composed and usually unique, even if its using artificial means, most of the music is not just a set beat, it generally has, intros, verses, etc.
And ill say it once again, certain rap / hip-hop I like, but I cant call it music, its not made like music, its made like poetry, shitty poetry with "bad words" scattered through it speaking very blatently about "gang style life" it is still a form of poetry.
To me, Calling Rap / Hip-hop music is like calling Demotivational posters works of art.