Shepherd492 reviews: Fifteen Hours/Skin Deep by Mitchel Scanlon - Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
post #1 of 3 (permalink) Old 05-18-12, 07:27 PM Thread Starter
Shepherd492's Avatar
Shepherd492's Flag is: Belarus
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 48
Reputation: 1
Default Shepherd492 reviews: Fifteen Hours/Skin Deep by Mitchel Scanlon

First review of a Warhammer book, I decided to include the short story as it was indirectly related and right after the book in the omnibus. I will probably include short stories in future reviews too (where applicable of course.) Any feedback would be great! You can check out this review, and many others, at Also note that my reviews use the entire 100 point scale- 1-20 correlates to a one star review on Amazon, 21-40= two star and so on. Feedback would be great!

Fifteen Hours and its corresponding short story, Knee Deep, are an intimate look at the inner workings of the Imperial Guard. Told through the eyes of Arvin Larn, a recent draftee, we explore the daily life of an Imperial Guardsmen on the frontlines of battle against the Orks. Despite a decent premise and good background information, Fifteen Hours is ruined by terrible characterization, dull writing, and a meandering plot.

The story starts off on Larn's homeworld of Jumael. In a bizarre twist, the story here actually seems to be very similar to World War I, outside of a few choice nouns. The rural community in which he lives, culture of Jumael, and architecture of his home feel like anything other than the far, far future the story is ostensibly set in. Larn is drafted into a Regiment of "volunteers" that share his homeworld, and shipped off to basic training after hearing a patently false story from his father.

After training, Larn and his comrades are sent via clerical error to the city of Broucheroc. After a disastrous landing sequence, Larn finds himself in the company of four veterans of the conflict, all of the Vardan Rifles regiment. Much of what Larn learns about the world, and basically all of his character interactions from here on out deal with these four characters, so they are rather important to the story. Unfortunately it would be hard to come up with a more bland cast to pair this clueless, hopelessly naive character with. We get a stereotypical grizzled vet in Davir, a guy who does nothing but spout exposition in Scholar, an inexplicably kind hearted soldier in Bulaven, and a creepy, borderline psychopathic loner in Zeebers. None of these characters develop the slightest amount of depth, and ultimately pile on to the horribly bland characterization that plagues every character in this book.

Larn is something of an everyman here. We experience the events of the story through his eyes, and his (annoying, all encompassing) naiveté serves as a good excuse for narrative exposition and explanations by his new squad mates. We learn about the situation on Broucheroc, the Orks, and the doctrine that the Vardan Rifles are currently engaging in. Some of the more unpleasant elements of trench warfare are also explained to him. Unfortunately, the short scope of the novel (just a handful of hours from the time Larn lands on the planet) and relative veterancy of his companions leave several important questions left unanswered. Among them are the methods that Davir and his friends use to cope with being stranded in a hellscape for ten years. It never comes up in conversation and Larn never experiences anything like it as the story is over less than a day after it begins- the sense of grinding, dangerous monotony that the rest of the Vardan Rifles must have felt never works its way into Larn's thoughts or the writing style of the story. Ultimately Larn's quest becomes one of proving himself and surviving for a brief duration instead of self preservation and long term decay. The trench warfare elements that frame the conflict would have been more effective with a story that took place over a longer period of time, the short duration fails to bring out the most intriguing aspects of such horrific combat.

Where the writing is concerned, the book is seriously flawed. Simplistic sentence structure, bland imagery, and occasionally confusing action sequences color the work. One of the things that irritated me the most was the strange formalized dialogue that rarely ever featured a contraction other than "don't" and felt extremely out of place among the gnarly band of grizzled veterans that make up the book's supporting cast. The action sequences are essentially the same moment- Orks charge the front lines, Guards nearly overrun, repeated two or three times, with no sense of urgency and precious little excitement. The Orks are certainly terrifying antagonists, but for much of the story they are a distant threat, lurking across a hellish no man's land and far from Larn's thoughts.

One of my favorite elements of the book were the various interludes that took us into the heads of people in other branches of Imperial Service. These moments often have disastrous results for the Vardan Rifles, and help to shed some light on the various elements of the Imperial Guard. Of particular interest is the propaganda writer desperately searching for a way to spin the latest news of the day, ultimately omitting half the story of the 14th Jumael "Volunteer" regiment's arrival. Also included is the stereotypical pompous glory hound lording over the defense of Broucheroc, and a non-combatant who has possibly the worst job ever- and is the cause behind Larn's arrival on Broucheroc. Insightful and darkly humorous, these sections were among my favorite in the book.

Knee Deep is set roughly two days after the events of Fifteen Hours. It features three of Larn's squad mates from that book, along with the erstwhile Sgt. Chelkar, and the rest of the Vardan Rifles as they attempt to cleanse the sewers of an Ork infestation. How much you will enjoy this story largely hinges on what you thought of Davir, Scholar, and Bulaven. The dynamic between the three is the biggest force at work here, along with some decent battle sequences in the expansive drainage tunnels. The matter is ultimately solved tidily (a bit too easily for my tastes) and the battle for Broucheroc rages on without consequence. Not a terrible short story, but of limited interest to those who didn't enjoy Larn's companions (like myself.)

The story of the Vardan Rifles is a decidedly mediocre one. Larn is simply too bland to carry what is essentially a character driven story. His supporting cast is extremely weak too, providing the necessary exposition but very little depth. Worst of all, the writing fails to bring any of it to life, rendering the setting and the antagonists completely stale. There are some good passages about other elements of the Imperial Guard, and hardcore fans will appreciate the explanation of various elements of life as a Guardsmen, but there is nothing here that would cause me to recommend this book to the average reader.

Final Score
33/100 My book review blog, in which I review sci fi books, mainly of the tie in variety (love Star Wars)

New to Warhammer 40k gentle!
Shepherd492 is offline  
Sponsored Links
post #2 of 3 (permalink) Old 05-18-12, 10:09 PM
Senior Member
Hachiko's Avatar
Hachiko's Flag is: USA
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 219
Reputation: 2

Hey shepherd, very good overall review (not biased, covered all the relevant points), and a nice looking blog too.

One thing you kindly omitted was the complete overusage of the cornball term "new fish". This above all annoyed me about this book.

Your assessment of the writing style is spot-on, Scanlon was/is not BL's finest author in the stable.
Another problem with the story: obviously the story was 'inspired by' All Quiet on the Westen Front. I have no problem with basing sci-fi or fantasy books on real events, or classic works, in fact I think it is good to put a twist on them. But please, leave the soul of the work intact. By making the enemies a horde of orks, there goes All Quiet's message of the 'enemy' being the same as 'us'. Missed opportunity. If the baddies were cultists of a sympathetically portrayed philosophy, compared with the bumbling, self-serving, Imperial hierarchy, we'd have potential for a good piece of reading. A different author would help too.
Hachiko is offline  
post #3 of 3 (permalink) Old 05-19-12, 12:21 AM Thread Starter
Shepherd492's Avatar
Shepherd492's Flag is: Belarus
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 48
Reputation: 1

Good points Hachiko, I really didn't like the Orks in this book for a different reason but that is good thinking too.

I forgot how much new fish annoyed me during my read through, oops!

Reading the second book in the omnibus now, Death World by Steve Lyons, and it is amazing how differently the Imperial Guard is portrayed in that novel. Also the writing has yet to put me to sleep, but that is a tale for another time! My book review blog, in which I review sci fi books, mainly of the tie in variety (love Star Wars)

New to Warhammer 40k gentle!
Shepherd492 is offline  

  Lower Navigation
Go Back   Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums > Fiction, Art and Roleplay Game Discussion > Black Library Book Reviews

Quick Reply

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the Wargaming Forum and Wargamer Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome