According to my mathhammer, a Destroyer Lord stands the best bet in CC. 4 attacks on the charge, 2 success, 2 rerolls, for 3 hits. S7 wounds his T5 on a 2+, meaning 2.49 successes and .51 rerolls, meaning 2.913 wounds. Conversely, Ghazghkulls innate 4 attacks need a 3+ to hit, which is 2.6 hits, and then a 2+ to wound, which is 2.2 wounds. I actually out-wound him, statistically, but he also has 4 wounds. In the second round of the challenge he will be dead first- Lets also not forget that MSS succeeds against LD10 about 48% of the time, meaning if the first failed, the second has good odds of succeeding, and he'll just ID himself with his Power Klaw. Unless he has Eternal Warrior? In which case he will probably already be dead or down to one wound anyway since you strike before him.
As for shooting, Monolith looks nice, as its S8 pie plate will Instant Death his Nobs, denying them any FNP if they have a Painboy.
Last edited by Iron Angel; 07-13-12 at 08:54 PM.