Critique for da CriticGod
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Philadelphia, PA USA
I think you've set yourself tough criteria. Fantasy games by the nature of the setting tend to be less skirmish and more model heavy.
If it was still in print I'd recommend Chronopia, which was the fantasy companion to the original Warzone. It was pretty dark, but not at all steampunk.
There's a site with a lot of info at chronopiaworld.com including Pdf's of the rules. The miniatures and rules are still available through Prince August games. The miniatures are somewhat uneven. Some are pretty awesome, others silly.
Best of luck finding a new game!