Well I haven't read Razumov's Tomb, but thanks for the advice about it, I'm intrigued now.
And you know I hadn't thought of those things about Dragonmage, but I suppose I just read without thinking and don't think that deeply. I would say that Wraight writes elves in general better than Werner, and I agree with you about the Slann stuff, unexpected and abrupt.
Haha, good way of putting it, tree-huggy, but I see what you mean. I suppose Werner was trying to portray the elves as sot of 'noble defenders' of Athel Loren or something similar.
I've read the first Thanquol book, and it was the reason I bought THoS because I just wanted more skaven afterwards!
Oh, and I didn't mean to get defensive, but thanks for the rep!
I seriously do just put instinctual scores, and it usually works out. But thanks for the debate, and the rep, repped back cause you're awesome